76: Case 41 Something to Hide Carolyn Keene

#41 The Nancy Drew Files

Tags:
A rash of crimes erupt when Nancy investigates a new beauty cream

Archive

Agent of Fortune

ZING

FancyShark

SAME!

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Marcia really sucks.

Agent of Fortune

High schoolers are brutal

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

I dont have a joke about that, fuck her.

FancyShark

The best parties feel like a suicide pact

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Slap that girl, Brad.

gellaho

Nancy knows that showing emotion is a sign of weakness to Georges

Agent of Fortune

😱

FancyShark

GASP!

Ozzie

Nancy activates Detective Mode

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

OH DO YOU THINK, NANCY?!

FancyShark

WHAT COULD IT HAVE BEEN, BOOK THAT MENTIONED POISONED FACE CREAM ON THE BACK COVER?!

Badgerman

She just ate a handful of silica packets before the book started, everybody calm down

Agent of Fortune

wait poisoned FACE CREAM?

Badgerman

It's a known quantity

gellaho

Nancy is a great detective

Agent of Fortune

That's dumb

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Do you think maybe the fact that Justin was freaking out was maybe suspicious in retrospect?!

LyraV

Damn it Nancy

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Nancy you KNOW Bess doesnt eat food.

FancyShark

We're going to go through every possible form of poisoning before Nancy figures it out, aren't we?

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"It must be from her job at the cadmium centrifuge!"

gellaho

Apparently the blood test came back with just "poison"

gellaho

Because that's how that works

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"Or her other job painting radium onto old timey watch dials!"

FancyShark

"But Bess doesn't even like eating poison!"

Badgerman

"It was some kind of chemical"

So we've narrowed it down to, oh, fucking everything

1000 Space GDCs

well, a chemical. that narrows it down

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"It must have been that shady Floridian lemonade!"

1000 Space GDCs

damn

FancyShark

The diagnosis chart is a skull and crossbones

Agent of Fortune

BESS ATE ANCHOVIES

Case solved

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Shes turning into a pelican now!

gellaho

This needs quotes or italics or something

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

By weeks end she'll be swallowing pigeons.

Agent of Fortune

Are you a pelican or a pelican't

FancyShark

"She was poisoned by pigeons!"

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Nancy........its OBVIOUSLY Justin and maybe Brad.

You silly moo.

Agent of Fortune

Nancy's instincts rival Joe and Frank's

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Just go and kill both of them and toss in Marcia for being a catty bitch.

Your old timey car deffo has the trunk space for three bodies.

FancyShark

It's why Frank has an actual crush on her. They're two robots wearing flesh

gellaho

Everything is warm

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

God he calls his girlfriend "Nan" like shes his grandmother.

Agent of Fortune

Cover her what

Badgerman

I'm glad no attempt was made to identify the "he" speaking here. Very natural human interaction

FancyShark

Ned panics when he doesn't at least have something that smells like Nancy

Badgerman

Have to leave some clothes out with her scent on it so he can find his way home like a lost cat

gellaho

I'm sure they didn't sell anymore lemonade, Nancy

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

You......stupid..........the LEMONADE and not the FACE CREAM?!

FancyShark

There are bodies all over the sidewalk. Nancy thinks it might be a clue.

Agent of Fortune

Why would they keep any

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

For the employees to drink.

Suicide pact.

Badgerman

Poison is expensive, Nancy, they're not just gonna sell it to every Johnny on the street

Agent of Fortune

Do they sort shitty lemonade by brewing date

FancyShark

Charge extra. With the right marketing, people buy anything

gellaho

Was it?

It was.

Agent of Fortune

Depends on the poison , drain cleaner is relatively cheap

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Marica calling her boyfriend to gloat about how catty she was today.

FancyShark

This reads like the ending of Blair Witch

gellaho

Nancy Drew chapter endings. Rule #1: Exclamation points!

Agent of Fortune

DO IT

Do it now

FancyShark

DO IT

Badgerman

Screaming about blackmail in a public space like a true master criminal

FancyShark

What's weird is Marcia's talking to her grandma about the lovely sweater she made

gellaho

Marcia is very good at hiding things

gellaho

Almost like she has

FancyShark

Marcia's hand slowly reaches for her tazer

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"Well you were howling threats into a payphone like the Unabomber."

Badgerman

Jesus Christ, Nancy, did you steal that hat from Buster Keaton?

gellaho

I'M NOT SUSPICIOUS

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Nancy is a bad detective.

Agent of Fortune

Or

Hear me out

The best detective

FancyShark

This makes more sense if you imagine Nancy's moving three seconds behind in time

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Nancy might be Mary Marvel in disguise.

Badgerman

"Listen: Nancy Drew has come unstuck in time."

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Wave at her left handedly and see if she still recognizes you.

1000 Space GDCs

Nancy is only certain of the facts she beats out of suspects.

Agent of Fortune

I lay down to take a nap but dammit Book Cage you've sucked me in

Brendan

Boys are from Hardy, Nancies are from Veronica Mars

FancyShark

When she says she wants "The Truth", she's referring to the chain-wrapped baseball bat she keeps in her car

Agent of Fortune

That would rule

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

She does warn people they cant handle "The Truth"

gellaho

Turns out "Florida Fresh" is two old folks selling Country Time powdered lemonade

FancyShark

And "The Truth" hurts

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Country time half tea and half lemonade mix fucks.

Brendan

Selling coke in lemonade power at a steep discount is such a perfectly stupid Nancy Drew crime.

FancyShark

"Why you eyein' my poisoned lemon drink?"

FancyShark

The sales figures are nothing to sneeze at

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Mrs Anderson seems helpful, but immediately after Nancy leaves she gets out her burner and dials, and when the other end picks up she says "The jig is up. I need a passport to Hong Kong and a fake name TONIGHT."

gellaho

Nancy loves using her friend's sickness to get out of awkward situations

1000 Space GDCs

"See, this carton is even labelled "not poison"!

FancyShark

"I have to go. Because...one of you is evil and poisons people."

gellaho

This is definitely two human beings talking to each other

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Brad is suspiciously concerned about the welfare of the girl he just met, and I dunno if thats me being cynical or something the author meant me to think.

gellaho

Definitely realistic hu-man conversation

Badgerman

"I have to use the poison! I mean the bathroom!"

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

The girl is convinced because Brad is a handsome college lad.

1000 Space GDCs

"We saw someone from your company say it was dangerous yesterday, what was that about?"

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Fifteen minutes later she drops dead, head swollen like a tomato.

FancyShark

Saving this, because it will be even better once all context is forgotten

Badgerman

"Can you tell me the ingredients so I don't set off my severe allergies?"

"No, but I'm sure it's fine 🙂 "

"You've convinced me, handsome lad!"

Brendan

Early attempts at guerrilla marketing were clumsy to say the least.

gellaho

Marcia decides this is a great time to get into comedy

Brendan

Not like today's subliminal mastery. Why, it's like I was saying to Brockway when I had just finished praising CARRIER WAVE, I said "Can you believe these NLP gurus? It's like something out of your hit novel, CARRIER WAVE!"

1000 Space GDCs

"They all said something about 'no loads refused'".

FancyShark

A nearby geiger counter goes ballistic when the jar gets close

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"You get it George? Cos you're a spotty pizza face!"

gellaho

Brad runs out of the mall crying

Agent of Fortune

Five more people!

1000 Space GDCs

"I didn't tell you because you're a suspect, duh"

FancyShark

"Wow! Lemonade sales were brisk!"

"Dammit, Nancy"

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"Because you wanting to fuck my fat ugly friend Bess was too suspicious an idea so I assumed you might have been poisoning her."

"Also I thought it was lemonade, because I'm kinda dumb."

Badgerman

The ending is Nancy going into Project Purity to start the cream decontamination machine with Bess' favorite Bible verse

Agent of Fortune

The lesson is don't buy mom and pop face cream

gellaho

Nancy goes to visit Beth. She meets a very open nurse

Badgerman

"You're in luck! Five people are on the brink of death 😀"

FancyShark

"Shift change in an hour. We don't lock the medicine cabinets. And the guards have no weapons. Bye!"

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"What? No of course you dont have to really know them or be family. HIPAA violations havent been invented yet."

1000 Space GDCs

Damn, scooped on the HIPAA joke.

gellaho

Teenagers talk like residents of old folks homes, right?

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"Just go ahead and disturb these poisoning victims, random teen girl."

Badgerman

"Oh thank god. Do you have games on your phone?"

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Also Nancy you are in fucking high school, you aren't a private detective.

Agent of Fortune

I'm Nancy Drew, I'm a HEAVY AIR QUOTES private detective

1000 Space GDCs

You don't need to say anything other than 'I want my lawyer", Bonnie.

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

If you were, you'd know you cant just lie like that, its legally actionable.

gellaho

Nancy has no sympathy for these weirdly named victims

FancyShark

Tiffany "Internal Bleeding" Weld

Agent of Fortune

The real Tiffany Weld

1000 Space GDCs

The only person with useful information disgusts Nancy.

Badgerman

Todd Leithauser is giving you valuable warning signs, Nancy, that information could save lives

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Tiffany Weld is like six feet tall and shredded, is into cars.

LyraV

I'm sure listening to the victim and their symptoms wouldn't help solve anything just breeze on by that Nancy

gellaho

I bet Beth thought that was hilarious

Badgerman

Boom roasted

FancyShark

Douglas Brody? Don't trust him

1000 Space GDCs

Tiffany Weld has a tattoo sleeve by an artist that's booked 16 months in advance.

Badgerman

Bet the lunch ladies are gonna think about that one for weeks

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Unlike the cafeteria chicken!

gellaho

I'm guessing George hates her cousin

Agent of Fortune

Fuuuuck

Badgerman

Go fuck yourself, George.

gellaho

Just keep telling yourself it's just a movie

FancyShark

George was already asked to not go in the cancer ward

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"Hahahahha its cos you're fat, Bess."

Brendan

I hope Bess and Chet drive 50 miles every weekend for an absolute fuckfeast in a beautiful lakeside motel.

gellaho

If you can't trust a failed chemistry major to test poison, who can you trust?

Badgerman

Nancy Drew drives a fucking Mustang?!?!

1000 Space GDCs

Justin is the Chet of the story.

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Nancy Drew cannot possibly be cool enough for a Mustang.

Agent of Fortune

It's where she keeps The Truth

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Damn tho convincing people you are a fucking detective at 17 is lucrative.

Badgerman

Nancy Drew isn't even cool enough for Turbo Teen

Brendan

Former Mustang owner: it has forever been the car of <25 guys and >45 yo women. Which, technically, Nancy is by the time this book was written.

1000 Space GDCs

Justin's out burst about the poisoned makeup has still not been brought up.

FancyShark

They've invented acts that would make Dr. Kinsey vomit

gellaho

At least the Hardy Boys had some access to police resources, Nancy Drew only has her attorney father and a doorstop she calls a boyfriend

Brendan

They deserve to be happy and fat.

gellaho

"Fun times."

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

I dont even think Bess is, I just think George is mean to her about her weight.

FancyShark

And he was named after the sound a door makes when it hits him

Badgerman

S c a r e ?

1000 Space GDCs

And the tire iron in the trunk of her mustang.

FancyShark

That classic prank

Badgerman

They put cyanide in medication and it only qualifies as a scare??

Brendan

Pretty scary to think someone could die after taking just half a dozen sleeping pills.\

FancyShark

In their defense, it took a while for people to notice. They thought the sleeping pills were really effective

gellaho

Ned can recognize a good chemist due to his upbringing in the alien lab where he spawned

Juho

Pfft, lightweight, that and a bottle of gin is how I sleep most nights.

FancyShark

"He was chemistring with the best of them!"

<cut to Ned staring at a poptart in a toaster>

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"He did this thing with a tube."

"You mean he took out the stopper?"

"Yeah it was amazing."

gellaho

They go to meet Marcia. And you'll never guess what happened

Badgerman

"It felt weird while we were doing it, but I kinda liked it."

1000 Space GDCs

Justin's former colleagues will tell you that his chemistry skills were not the reason he was forced to resign.

gellaho

The ghostwriter forgot the goshdarned exclamation point!

gellaho

Also, she got poisoned

Badgerman

And there was much rejoicing

gellaho

World class detective

Brendan

Marcia Grafton, lemonade enthusiast

FancyShark

Chief McGinnis. I assume that's an Italian name

Brendan

These no-good eye-talians and their shileighlighelighhs

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Oh well if Marcia got poisoned, its probably fine.

Badgerman

Man, Terry really went a different way after Bruce finally passed

"What happened to her 👁👄👁"

1000 Space GDCs

Turns out Marcia just has an opioid addiction, nothing to worry about.

gellaho

"Him?"

1000 Space GDCs

Ned's been introduced like a dozen times, but no one can remember him.

FancyShark

"Faith and begorrah, you kiddin' me Italian ears, missie? Wot kinda name's Nickerson?"

Brendan

"Hi, I'm Ned. My girlfriend got me on The List"

Badgerman

"You settled for this clown?"

Brendan

"Let this boy into the murder attempt!"

gellaho

Nancy just rocking back and forth in this police car, thinking nobody notices

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"Wait........NED Nickerson? The Chattanooga Strangler! He's been wanted for years!"

Badgerman

Way to implicate yourselves at the crime scene, Ned

1000 Space GDCs

Nancy is sitting in the bodily fluids of the guy who just got dropped off in the drunk tank

gellaho

But Ned's face always looked like that

FancyShark

Since when does the chief of police go to the crime scene?

Or is "Chief" his first name?

Badgerman

It was on the way to Dunkin

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Oh the cops dont think you're connected, they just doodled on that paper to get you to confess.

FancyShark

"We know at least two of the victims and have been seen at multiple crimes scenes. But otherwise, I don't know what they'd have on us."

gellaho

So the police, actually doing an investigation for once in these books, figure out before Nancy that all of these people are involved in this poisoning.

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"I dont see how our knowing the victims and being around crime scenes is a connection at all, Ned. We need to follow up on my lemonade lead."

gellaho

And it looks like Nancy is going to get Justin sent to prison

Badgerman

If only she'd listened to Todd

FancyShark

"Chemistry test" is what Justin calls masturbating

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"Well I was trying to figure out what kind of poison might have been in this lemonade a girl gave me to test. Its stupid but I figured it would make her feel better."

gellaho

The best detective in town

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Which Ned would find equally amazing.

Badgerman

"Popping the stopper"

FancyShark

@gellaho , please let us know when Swiper shows up

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

And as we all know, once you pop, you have to finish all over your lab partner.

gellaho

This entire town has brain damage

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Nancy Drew and the Case of the Lead Contamination Scandal.

Badgerman

"Good thinking" with the slow nod feels extremely patronizing. I wonder if the chief is in on the joke

1000 Space GDCs

Nancy fails to recognize the condescension in his voice.

Brendan

There's no scandal if the local government refuses to do anything and pretends it's normal so long it becomes a point of pride among the townies

FancyShark

Every mystery is Nancy's Make A Wish

Brendan

Yeah we got da lead inna WATUH go back to Philly if that makes youse SCAWED

gellaho

Nancy may not be suited for this whole detective business

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

"We like flippers actually, it makes it easier to swim in our lovely lakes. And the hydrocephaly makes you very buoyant."

Badgerman

Yeah, it's a Dennis Nedry, book, we get it

FancyShark

The padding on this story is amazing

1000 Space GDCs

That was shameful shiver, Nancy.

Brendan

alrighty, time to go comic-con drinking.

safe sleuthing, youths.

Badgerman

Have fun! Be safe!

gellaho

Is Heather secretly a snail?

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Nasty Nancy getting her sleuthing cummies.

FancyShark

What @Badgerman said!

gellaho
Badgerman

I picture Justin running like Alex Jones.

1000 Space GDCs

Justin's about to get tazed.

Badgerman

Just going the fucking hardest he can but never getting anywhere. Like he's playing with bad ping

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Screaming at Heather about snakes underfoot and gay frogs.

gellaho

This appears to have turned Heather into a malfunctioning robot

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Gee Nancy, you think this might be a clue?

Badgerman

<sees the most suspicious shit ever>

"Are you okay 👁👄👁"

FancyShark

If your whole face is twitching, is it everything convulsing at once or is it like a series of gnats are flitting across your face?

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Strawberry blondes give redheads a bad name.

gellaho

It's also very weird that the police aren't confiscating any of this poisoned makeup, and the teens are just taking it home

LyraV

yes

FancyShark

Take an evidence, leave an evidence

1000 Space GDCs

The janitor arrives to clean Justin's blood off the wall and apply some spackle.

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

I assume alot of the teens are also detectives so they need it to solve cases.

Badgerman

If they want it they can come back with a warrant. Til then, the poisonings continue

gellaho

"She didn't notice these things I'm describing"

FancyShark

"I just want you all to know it was a nice day outside of this story"

LyraV

Frankly she wasn't even sure she had a plan.

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

One thing you have to give the Hardy boys. By now, someone would have attempted to murder them.

FancyShark

There would have been at least one van explosion or buffet trip

Horse Boxing Flippant Sausage

Nancy is just a little teen FDA narc with a cool car.